Print
E-mail
Comment
Rate
Reform leader slams Conservative Jewry
By: JOE BERKOFSKY Jewish Telegraphic Agency
A top Reform rabbi is predicting the death of Conservative Judaism, drawing protests from the Conservative movement's leadership.
The objections surfaced this week in response to an essay by Rabbi Paul Menitoff, executive vice president of the Reform movement's Central Conference of American Rabbis. The essay argued that within several decades Conservative Jews likely will move either to the more liberal Reform movement or to the more traditional Orthodox world.
Major wedges between the modernist movements will force this exodus, Menitoff argued, including the Conservative movement's opposition to intermarriage; its ban on ordaining homosexual rabbis and on same-sex marriages; and its opposition to patrilineal descent, all of which the Reform movement supports.
The Conservative movement may continue to attract those for whom Orthodoxy remains "too restrictive" and Reform "too acculturated," but a more likely outcome will be "the demise of the Conservative movement," Menitoff wrote.
Conservative leaders called the argument "delusional" and the product of "immature" analysis.
"His description of the future is rather silly," said Rabbi Joel Meyers, executive vice president of the Conservative movement's Rabbinical Assembly. The essay "is an immature look" at the currents shaping American Jewry, he said, "or maybe it's wishful thinking."
Unusual in its bluntly pessimistic predictions, Menitoff's essay comes as Conservative Jewry, which once dominated the American Jewish landscape, is facing major challenges.
In the past few years, the movement has been split over major issues, including its stance on homosexuality. Some rabbis have accused the movement's leadership of lacking vision.
Menitoff's predictions came in a January missive to the Central Conference of American Rabbis' 1,800 members. He later outlined the premise at a joint meeting of the western chapters of the rabbinical group and its Conservative counterpart, the Rabbinical Assembly
Some signs lend weight to Menitoff's theory. Last September, the 2000-01 National Jewish Population Survey found that of the nation's 4.3 million Jews with some religious or communal connections, the largest group - 39% - identified as Reform, while 33% called themselves Conservative.
That represented a major decline from the 43% the Conservative movement polled in the 1990 NJPS. By contrast, the Reform movement rose during that period from 35%, and Orthodoxy grew to 21% from 16%. The Reconstructionist movement rose to 3% from 2%.
Menitoff also pointed to the disparity between attendance at the Conservative movement's 2003 biennial convention in Dallas, which some 500 people attended, and the Reform summit in Minneapolis, which drew nearly 5,000.
Conservative movement officials rejected Menitoff's point. "That's just not a measure of success - their convention is structured differently than ours," said Sarrae Crane, director of the Conservative convention, which is aimed principally at the movement's leadership.
Though Menitoff lamented the blurring of denominational lines as the result of "extreme assimilation" - 44% of Jews do not align with any movement, according to the NJPS - his Conservative counterparts felt they were being attacked.
"It's his delusional thinking that creates this scenario," said Rabbi Jerome Epstein, executive vice president of the United Synagogue, the Conservative movement's congregational arm.
"The Talmud says prophecy has been taken away from the prophets and given to children and fools," said Rabbi Bradley Shavit Artson, dean and vice president of the Ziegler School of Rabbinic Studies at the University of Judaism in Los Angeles, one of the Conservative movement's two main seminaries. He and others pointed out that a century ago, many predicted the death of the Orthodox movement and were proven wrong.
"I would tell him to be very cautious," Rabbi Ismar Schorsch, chancellor of the Jewish Theological Seminary in New York, said of Menitoff. Many once said, "Orthodoxy would not be able to withstand reasoned science and critical scholarship," Schorsch said, but "all the pundits proved to be rank amateurs."
The objections surfaced this week in response to an essay by Rabbi Paul Menitoff, executive vice president of the Reform movement's Central Conference of American Rabbis. The essay argued that within several decades Conservative Jews likely will move either to the more liberal Reform movement or to the more traditional Orthodox world.
Major wedges between the modernist movements will force this exodus, Menitoff argued, including the Conservative movement's opposition to intermarriage; its ban on ordaining homosexual rabbis and on same-sex marriages; and its opposition to patrilineal descent, all of which the Reform movement supports.
The Conservative movement may continue to attract those for whom Orthodoxy remains "too restrictive" and Reform "too acculturated," but a more likely outcome will be "the demise of the Conservative movement," Menitoff wrote.
Conservative leaders called the argument "delusional" and the product of "immature" analysis.
"His description of the future is rather silly," said Rabbi Joel Meyers, executive vice president of the Conservative movement's Rabbinical Assembly. The essay "is an immature look" at the currents shaping American Jewry, he said, "or maybe it's wishful thinking."
Unusual in its bluntly pessimistic predictions, Menitoff's essay comes as Conservative Jewry, which once dominated the American Jewish landscape, is facing major challenges.
In the past few years, the movement has been split over major issues, including its stance on homosexuality. Some rabbis have accused the movement's leadership of lacking vision.
Menitoff's predictions came in a January missive to the Central Conference of American Rabbis' 1,800 members. He later outlined the premise at a joint meeting of the western chapters of the rabbinical group and its Conservative counterpart, the Rabbinical Assembly
Some signs lend weight to Menitoff's theory. Last September, the 2000-01 National Jewish Population Survey found that of the nation's 4.3 million Jews with some religious or communal connections, the largest group - 39% - identified as Reform, while 33% called themselves Conservative.
That represented a major decline from the 43% the Conservative movement polled in the 1990 NJPS. By contrast, the Reform movement rose during that period from 35%, and Orthodoxy grew to 21% from 16%. The Reconstructionist movement rose to 3% from 2%.
Menitoff also pointed to the disparity between attendance at the Conservative movement's 2003 biennial convention in Dallas, which some 500 people attended, and the Reform summit in Minneapolis, which drew nearly 5,000.
Conservative movement officials rejected Menitoff's point. "That's just not a measure of success - their convention is structured differently than ours," said Sarrae Crane, director of the Conservative convention, which is aimed principally at the movement's leadership.
Though Menitoff lamented the blurring of denominational lines as the result of "extreme assimilation" - 44% of Jews do not align with any movement, according to the NJPS - his Conservative counterparts felt they were being attacked.
"It's his delusional thinking that creates this scenario," said Rabbi Jerome Epstein, executive vice president of the United Synagogue, the Conservative movement's congregational arm.
"The Talmud says prophecy has been taken away from the prophets and given to children and fools," said Rabbi Bradley Shavit Artson, dean and vice president of the Ziegler School of Rabbinic Studies at the University of Judaism in Los Angeles, one of the Conservative movement's two main seminaries. He and others pointed out that a century ago, many predicted the death of the Orthodox movement and were proven wrong.
"I would tell him to be very cautious," Rabbi Ismar Schorsch, chancellor of the Jewish Theological Seminary in New York, said of Menitoff. Many once said, "Orthodoxy would not be able to withstand reasoned science and critical scholarship," Schorsch said, but "all the pundits proved to be rank amateurs."
 |
 |
|
| Latest news briefs from the Jewish Telegraphic Agency | Who has John Kerry's ear on Jewish issues? |
Article Rating
Reader Comments
The following are comments from the readers. In no way do they represent the view of clevelandjewishnews.com.
You must register with a valid email to post comments. Only your Member ID will be posted with the comments. Registration is free.
Registered users sign in here: |
Become a Registered User |
