KARNEI SHOMRON, Israel – An Associated Press article that first popped up in my Twitter feed last week almost caused me to spit my coffee all over my computer screen.

The writer of the article sounds surprised that people like me, settlers who live in the West Bank, would be allowed to vote in Israeli elections since we do not live on what is considered “sovereign Israeli territory.”

Israel, the article explains, does not allow absentee voting for its citizens living abroad, except for diplomats and emissaries sent by the state. The article expresses amazement that the more than 350,000 Jews living in the West Bank do not fall under the category of Israeli citizens living abroad.

March 17 will be the fifth Israeli election in which I have voted. This is the first time that I can remember my right or ability to vote being questioned.

I pay taxes to Israel. My husband works in Tel Aviv. Two of my children attend school in Kfar Saba. My older daughter lives in the Hebrew University dormitories in Jerusalem. My second-oldest daughter is performing national service in the north of the country. I receive my mail through the Israeli postal service and I have an Israeli zip code. My passport identifies me as Israeli and lists my passport as being issued in Kfar Saba in central Israel. When I get a traffic ticket here it is issued by the Israel Police and I pay my fine to the state. Members of my community do and have in the past served in the Knesset.

No one should question my right to vote in Israel’s elections.

But the article and its question seem to have taken on a life of its own. A Google search of its first paragraph shows that it has been republished nearly 9,000 times. And in a sign that the question has taken hold in the minds of decision shapers, New York Times columnist Nicholas Kristof, who, granted, has no love lost for my community and others like it, invoked the question in a column that appeared three days later.

It was not the first time last week that my fellow West Bank residents and I came under attack (though you’d think we'd be used to it by now).

An annual Peace Now report released last week blared that there was a 40 percent increase in housing starts in the settlements for 2014. The report mentioned my community by name and even showed an aerial photograph of one of the housing projects, a project I can see from my upstairs window. I think you can even see my house in the aerial photograph.

I thought of the project later in the week, with the release of the state comptroller’s report on Israel’s housing crisis, which states that: “The government and its ministries have set national housing policy in a deficient manner.”

Isaac Herzog, leader of the Labor party and head of the coalition Zionist Union running in the current national elections, took the opportunity of the release of the report to blame the housing crisis on government spending in the settlements. He said that if the money spent on settlement housing like the new housing project in my neighborhood had been targeted at young couples looking to buy homes then there might not now be an Israeli housing crisis.

But the housing being built here reaches his exact target audience.

The majority of the 96 housing units being built two blocks from my home have been sold to young couples who currently are renting in my community or who are children of residents, the exact people that Herzog believes the money should have been spent on.

These couples just want to raise their children in the same warm and embracing community in which they grew up, instead of Tel Aviv and other major and unaffordable cities that other young couples desire.

There are two other major housing projects in other neighborhoods throughout my municipality, and in those cases the majority of the first-time homebuyers also are young couples returning to their roots.

Many of these young people work in central Israel, pay taxes to the Israeli government and delivered their babies in hospitals in Jerusalem or in central Israel. By buying a home in the West Bank community in which they grew up, they certainly are not planning to give up their right to vote.


Letters, commentaries and opinions appearing in the Cleveland Jewish News do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the Cleveland Jewish Publication Company, its board, officers or staff.

How do you feel about this article?

Choose from the options below.